Security for the Digital Transformation: Cloud, Data, Identity & Access.
Tuesday, July 2
Identity Officer
One of the things I've noticed over recent years is that big, brand name companies who are well-respected for their primary business and their ability to execute on internal IT projects have many little "messes" related to technology that nobody talks about. A mess could be a mistake (bad purchase, wrong implementer) or it could be something that started out OK and grew into a mess over time. One of the common messes out there is related to interconnectivity of various IAM solutions.
It looks like this: One group within the company bought Oracle or IBM for user account management and built a complex infrastructure around it that they're afraid to touch. Another bought SailPoint or Aveksa - maybe both - and incorporated 40% of the intended applications then the project stalled out. A third group is using Ping for Federation with partners while a fourth runs Microsoft FIM and ADFS to support other partners.
I recently spoke to the "Lead Architect for IAM" at one of the world's top banks. With a title like that, I figured he'd be in the middle of orchestrating the various interdependencies between IAM systems. When I mentioned an IAM brand name that I knew they had deployed, he said something like, "oh no, that's a different group". He knew it existed but didn't know much more about it.
In the above scenario, one obvious consideration is that there's time and money spent purchasing and implementing these technologies which have overlapping functionality. It's wasteful and inefficient. But there's a bigger problem with that scenario than cost and maintenance.
When the business wants to enable some new venture (new partnership, new regulation, M&A, etc.) it's extremely difficult to adapt to new requirements because of all the little messes that would need to be cleaned up. And which group should lead the effort? The access certification system is the newest and its owners have some political pull. But the provisioning system is larger, more established, and now supports the desired certification scenarios. Each of the four or five IAM systems has valuable data. How do you bring it all together to meet the immediate need?
I probably don't need to spell out where an Identity Officer could have made a positive impact in the above scenario. Reduced cost, reduced overhead, greater flexibility, speed to implement. I think Dave is on to something by reviving this topic. As a doctor of IAM, he's taking a holistic look at the identity needs of organizations. It's not just about technology or workflows. It's also about understanding executive ownership and aligning IAM with business needs. Organizational structure is a big part of that conversation.
Tuesday, June 30
Nobody gets fired for buying IBM
Being that my employer is a small, nimble, innovative software company, I especially liked this quote from CPS Energy CIO Christopher Barron:
"With software from smaller vendors, it can take 20% to 40% less time to implement, and if it works, it could save you between three and eight times as much. The catch, of course, is that it doesn't always work. But even failing seems to be cheaper than going with the big guys."I've always heard the adage that 'Nobody gets fired for buying IBM', meaning that even if you spend a little more, you're playing it safe by going with a trusted, well-known name. But the only projects I've ever heard becoming a colossal failure involve solutions from big name vendors with multi-million dollar price tags. And the really cool success stories you hear involve someone accomplishing something great with minimal budget.
Don't get me wrong - I know that many large businesses are run on big name solutions from IBM, SAP, Oracle and the like, but I think we need to be clear that the adage is not an axiom. That is, it's not self-evident. In fact, to some, it might even be nonsensical. Why would it make sense to spend 4x the amount of money to decrease your risk of over-expenditure?
What do you think? Does the adage hold up in today's economy? Will it hold up when we recover? Is it simply a question of finding the right solution for the job, or should it be part of a CIO's objective to put cost out in front of the decision?
Tuesday, February 24
Project Communication
I agree with each of his four bullet points. And I would add that when they collectively fail, the #1 reason is that people aren't being honest with each other. Sometimes, consultants aren't honest with clients about lack of expertise or resources. Other times, someone on the client side isn't being honest with the consultant because of some defensiveness (they don't want to admit inability to get something done, or they're playing CYA).
The reality is that we're all human. Clients shouldn't expect consultants to be super heroes. And if both sides set realistic expectations and allow for faults, imperfections, and mistakes, it's much easier to achieve an honest dialog toward success. Consultants need to avoid both (1) the arrogant assumption that client personnel is less capable and (2) the assumption that client personnel should know everything they do. And clients need to be forgiving of human/imperfect consultants who can't possibly know everything about everything.
There is a very human side to project management. It's not just charts and methodology. It's about making the problems, roadblocks, and challenges expected and OK. ...instead of trying to cover them up. So, don't just have regular status meetings, demand open and honest dialog and create an environment where it's OK to make mistakes. It's all part of the process.
Saturday, November 22
U of Rochester IdM Journal
[enter Leslie Nielsen]
"I just want to tell you both good luck. We're all counting on you."
Friday, November 21
Identity Management is Like Watching Paint Dry
On the humorous side, twenty one percent of respondents in an Imanami research report found managing Active Directory to be more boring than filling out expense reports. (It's great that they even included that option in the survey - it could be fodder for OfficeSpace 2?)
On the serious side (from the research):
And back to the article:5.8 person-hours per 1,000 users is spent during a typical week on updating or otherwise managing groups in Active Directory.
81% of respondent organizations manage groups manually, while 55% use scripts and 34% use some sort of automated solution.
I've talked about the motivations behind Identity Management projects before, but I wasn't accounting for the current economic climate. There's definitely an argument to be made that the pendulum is swinging back toward cost savings as the prime mover of Identity projects."User provisioning and multifactor authentication are two projects you should keep if you are thinking about cutting back," said Forrester Research's Andras Cser about identity management today. "These are areas where there's a real opportunity to increase efficiency and cost savings."
42% of organizations report that someone has accessed information from Active Directory that they were not authorized to access.
This issue becomes even more acute during difficult financial times, when employees may become disgruntled following layoffs or pay disputes, experts noted. During such times, the ability to quickly provision and deprovision employees may play an important role in the enterprise's overall security, they said.
Monday, April 14
Article: Business Case for IdM
Wednesday, May 23
Identity Management Success Factors
Please send me your list of the five most important factors that contribute to the success or failure of Identity Management projects.
I know this is going against the grain, but I think the reports of wide-spread failure of Identity projects are grossly exaggerated. At least, troubled projects are no more prevelant in the IdM space than they are in relation to other technology projects. Technology for enterprise information management is inherently complex. But, I've been a part of a number of successful projects - their success measured by the feedback of the project sponsor at the conclusion of the effort. And I've spoken to a number of people in the field who tell similar tales. I only occasionally hear a real horror story about an IdM project. Usually those troubles are based on misaligned expectations or poor project management. That is, an executive sponsor expects a project to solve 100 problems, but the implementation only solves 50 and it seems like a failure. Or a development team tries to build a solution based on a half-baked design which keeps changing and there's no change control in place so the project quickly falls off schedule and over budget.
With those comments in mind, here is my list:
- Establish clear and attainable objectives up front. This is vital. The only way to acheive success is to make the criteria for success clearly known and agreed-upon by all those involved. If this process is rushed or not clearly articulated, then there will be no consensus on the success of the project. While establishing criteria requires some knowledge of the business and the technology, this is primarily a perception issue -- not a business challenge and not a technology challenge. But, I think it deserves the #1 spot on the list.
- Strong Project Management. The project manager is the person who establishes the objectives and manages the project toward those objectives. In a complicated project involving complex business and technology challenges, strong management is extremely important to keep things on track.
- Build the Right Team. If the project requires interviews with business personnel, don't rely on a programmer and a DBA to deliver the project on their own. And don't expect a project manager to create a technical architecture. You need to understand the skills and roles required to reach your objectives as well as the capabilities of those on the team. Get the right team in place to cover all the roles. If the DBA is also a good business analyst, then maybe they can play two roles, but pay attention and spend the time and budget to build an effective team. I would also say that previous experience with the specific technology you're using would be great, but it's actually less important than having the right people in each role.
- Have a Project Champion at the Right Level. IdM projects cross organizational boundaries and sometimes cross organizations. They tend to need executive sponsorship. The projects that were easiest for me to get through were sponsored by the CEO (or other business leader) and not only the CIO (or related technical folks). I was once working as a consultant interviewing a phone system admin for a provisioning project. During the interview, he asked if we had seen the movie Office Space because he felt like he was interviewing for his own job. This was, of course, not the case. But, it illustrates the importance of executive sponsorship. If it was the AD admin instead of the CIO that had brought us in, we may have had trouble scheduling time with this particular gentleman.
- Build Cyclical Iterative Successes. Although I think the first four items are a sufficient recipe for success, if I had to come up with a fifth item that would make success more easily acheiveable, it would be to follow an iterative process rather than trying to do too much in a single project. Nothing builds momentum better than a few quick wins. In a large IdM rollout, this could mean having a project just to create an enterprise directory. Don't build the directory as the first step in the enterprise provisioning project but rather make the directory the result of it's own project. That success builds confidence amongst the team and the stakeholders. ...and divides up success into smaller, more easily measurable chunks.
There's definitely some overlap here with what Mark wrote. But honestly, I'd be more surprised if anyone presented a list that didn't have significant overlap. Thanks for the effort Mark!
Friday, September 22
Time to rethink your IdM strategy?
- Socrates
"The unexamined Identity Management solution is not worth the investment"
- Me
While not quite as eloquent as the original, my point is that we should apply Socrates' theory to business and IT strategy just as we apply it to the way we live our lives. I gave a nod to a blog post a while back that described Identity Management as a lifestyle. Yesterday, in an article entitled CIO Jury: Businesses face ID management headache, the CIO Jury reminds us that identity management is a lifestyle. You can't set it and forget it like Ron Popeil. You need to make a plan, start to build, re-evaluate, launch some functionality, re-evaluate, build some more, alter the plan, evaluate what's coming next, etc.. There are certainly technology components that will run on their own without constant maintenance, but they live at a very tactical level. At the strategic level, it's important to continually re-think the plan. The business climate as well as the technology landscape are both dynamic in nature. Change is constant. Keep this in mind during planning and be prepared to switch gears if needed.
In a recent MaXware webinar, a customer described the process of backing out of a big investment in IdM and starting again with an entirely new product set. The webinar will be available on the MaXware site and it's definitely worth the viewing time. One important take-away for me was that you can forfeit a major investment that's not working, completely shift gears and come out successful. It takes some guts and some ingenuity, but it can pay off. The webinar presented an excellent example of the value of constant re-evaluation.
Another point I want to make is that while planning an Identity services architecture, it's vital to build an environment that is flexible and adaptable. Take a look at Identicentric's idBUS product. They've got the right idea. Build a flexible service-oriented middleware layer that enables you to quickly adapt the front end apps or the back end infrastructure to the ever-changing business requirements. I've also talked in the past about Virtual Directory as a data abstraction layer providing similar capability but at a data access level rather than an application access level. Think about these approaches and how else you might enable your Identity Services infrastructure to adapt quickly to changing requirements.
And rethink your Identity Management strategy. It's always a good time for that.
Wednesday, March 22
Identity Management Project Continuum
I recently had a discussion with some sales folks who were interested in the Identity Management project lifecycle. The question came from a product sales perspective as in How do we know where a client stands in the big picture of IdM? ...or more pointedly How do we know which product to pitch to a given company based on how far along they are? I laid out what I like to call the Identity Management project continuum.
Implementing IdM is not a single project. Nor is it even a few stand-alone projects. I call it a continuum. The folks at TNT recently posted a blog describing IdM as a lifestyle. I think that's a great way to think about it. I was, though, a little annoyed about their claims regarding software vendors. They suggested that because we sell software we don't understand the customer perspective. I think they're wrong about that -- at least with some of us. In an ideal world, businesses looking to deploy IdM would have someone competent driving the boat -- maybe an employee, maybe a consultant, but probably not a software vendor. We provide tactical tools to get the job done but that doesn't mean we don't get the big picture. We just typically wouldn't want ownership of the big picture. That's not our focus.
To get back to the topic, the continuum is not black and white. It necessarily varies for every business based on their data, infrastructure, processes and business needs. For any given business, the phases will occur in different orders, their prioritations will vary and some phases may not be required at all.
Below is a sample outline of what I described as the continuum. It's meant to be a general guideline and a starting point for discussion. It's certainly not trying to be a one-size-fits-all project plan
Vision and Roadmap - This is important. You should identify and clearly document the goals, business drivers and overall approach. List the general timeframes and expectations.
Data Cleansing and Reconciliation - Most organizations have multiple data sources that are stored in different formats with different technologies. Step one is usually identifying the data sources, cleaning the data as-needed and creating attributes that can be used to join records together.
Basic Account Provisioning - The first step provisioning may be as simple as automated account creation but could also include single-step workflow or automation of group/role memberships.
Basic Password Management - Management of passwords is often a key driver for IdM projects due to the organizational cost savings.
Basic Auditing - This step should involve initiating the collection of audit data and a few basic reports. Advanced reporting based on captured data can be implemented down the road.
Build/Strengthen Centralized App Authentication - This can be implementing SSO, consolidating authentication mechanisms, reducing the number of authentication stores or otherwise improving the application authentication infrastructure.
Advanced Provisioning - Build upon the basic provisioning infrastructure with advanced workflow, additional business rules, improved deprovisioning functionality and inclusion of additional data sources and/or applications.
Internal Federation - With an established infrastructure for authentication and entitlement, federation may be the next step. Here you adopt a standard and think about how you want to pass authentication information across security boundaries.
External Federation - After the basic federation infrastructure is in place, you may be ready to enagage in cross-organizational federation with customers, service providers and partners.
One other thing...
While I'm writing about projects, I'd like to give a nod to a great set of blogs by Mark Dixon about IdM project risks. While I don't think the ideas are completely original (I'm sure Mark would agree), they are indeed brilliant. And Mark organizes and explains the information very well. If you are embarking on an IdM journey, these are a must read:
Seven Identity Mgt Implementation Risks, Mark Dixon (1/25/06)
Identity Risks - Poor Pre-Project Preparation, Mark Dixon (1/31/06)
Identity Risks - Poor Requirements Definition, Mark Dixon (2/04/06)
Identity Risks - Large Initial Scope, Mark Dixon (3/14/06)
Identity Risks - Inexperienced Resources, Mark Dixon (4/14/06)
Identity Risks - Poor Project Methodology, Mark Dixon (4/24/06)
Identity Risks - Scope Creep, Mark Dixon (7/26/06)
Identity Risks - Not Using Available Support, Mark Dixon (7/27/06)
I'm really glad Mark is writing about these. If he hadn't, I might have felt the need to try it myself. I probably wouldn't have done such a nice job and definitely wouldn't have had the audience reach. ...I look forward to reading more from Mark about the four other risks.